AI Robot Judges and Judicial Decision-Making: A Comparative Assessment in Light of Islamic Fiqh

Articles in Press

Document Type : Scholary

Authors

1 Assistant Professor of the Department of Fiqh and of Islamic Law, Shahid University ,Tehran, Iran

2 Scholar of the Department of Jurisprudence and Law of Qom Seminary

3 MA Student of International Law , Faculty of Law, Qom University , Qom , Iran

10.22059/jcis.2025.394346.1420

Abstract

The advancement of information technology, Artificial Intelligence (AI) in particular, has profoundly influenced various aspects of human life. Among these, the administration of justice—a matter of significant importance in view of the Divine Lawgiver (The Legislator in Islam)—has also been subject to technological transformation. AI-powered robot judges, capable of processing vast amounts of data with exceptional speed, accuracy, and efficiency, present a strategic advantage in judicial proceedings. However, a critical question arises: What are the Fiqhi (jurisprudential) implications of delegating judgment and justice to humanoid robots? Employing a descriptive-analytical-comparative methodology, this study examines the legal and doctrinal evidence surrounding the permissibility and prohibition of robot judges in Islam. The research concludes that, given the explicit designation of the position of judgeship to human beings by the Islamic Legislator—along with the inherent incompatibility of robotic entities with the nuanced responsibilities of judicial authority—autonomous judgment by robot judges cannot be deemed legitimate. Instead, such technology may serve as an auxiliary and complementary tool to enhance the efficiency, precision, and quality of judicial processes under the oversight of human judges.

Keywords

Main Subjects

Classical and Contemporary Islamic Studies

Articles in Press, Accepted Manuscript
Available Online from 17 July 2025

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics